1. Current Location: Home >  Comprehensive classification >  49 smart home routers, the WiFi version and the gateway version are more than a little different

49 smart home routers, the WiFi version and the gateway version are more than a little different

Smart home device network planning: Comparison between WiFi version direct connection and Zigbee gateway version and three questions about adding devices

Last week, my sweeping robot started on its own at 2 o'clock in the middle of the night. I got up and checked around, and found that it was not that it was convulsing, but that one of the smart devices attached to the router had disconnected and reconnected, messing up the entire 2.4G channel. The next day I did something I've never been too lazy to do: Open the Mijia App and count the device list from the beginning - 49 devices. After counting, I realized that the problem was not with the router. When I bought the equipment, I never thought about "which way will this device go after I get it home?" This article will break down this account clearly.

Count the equipment first: How did you save 49 units?

My main router is Xiaomi AX3000T, plus an old AC2100 for IoT private network. The composition of 49 stations is roughly like this: 4 mobile phones, 3 computers, 2 tablets, these are "real users"」 ; Below are all "smart residents" - 2 cameras, 1 sweeper, 2 smart speakers, and 1 TV box, which are directly connected to WiFi ; There are 8 light bulbs, 6 sockets, 12 temperature and humidity sensors, door and window sensors, 1 door lock, 2 air conditioning companions and infrared remote controls. This batch uses Zigbee and Bluetooth, all hanging under a 99-yuan multi-mode gateway.

After counting, I came to a key conclusion: Of these 49, only about 21 are actually crowded on the router, and the remaining 28 are not directly connected to the router at all. They are all hung under a gateway. In the past two years, I had no concept of buying equipment. I just bought whatever was convenient. I bought 8 WiFi version light bulbs in one go. Later I learned that each of these 8 light bulbs is considered as a "resident" of the router, while with the Zigbee version, the total of 8 light bulbs only counts as 1 resident.

I wrote an article before about router capacity. , it talks about how to troubleshoot and lose weight after the equipment is overloaded. It is the idea of ​​"rescuing the equipment after it is stuck". This article, in turn, talks about how to plan before adding equipment, so that the router does not have to be forced from the beginning.

What is the difference between WiFi version and gateway version?: Does it occupy space on the router?

When buying a smart device, the small words "WiFi version/Bluetooth version/Zigbee version" on the product page, many people think of it as a multiple-choice question about the connection method, but it is actually a multiple-choice question about the router load.

Once the WiFi version of the device is connected to your home WiFi, it will become an official terminal managed by the router. It will be treated like your mobile phone - it needs to account for the number of connections, obtain IP, and require regular heartbeats to keep it alive. The router has a nominal capacity of 64 and 128 units, which sounds quite large, but that number is the theoretical value of "can be connected." When there are more smart devices, the air interface in the 2.4G frequency band will not be able to support it.

Zigbee and Bluetooth devices are not connected to your router. They are connected to a "gateway" - a small, palm-sized box that plugs into the socket next to the router. All sub-devices talk to the gateway, which then aggregates them into a single line to the router. In other words, whether you have 20 sensors or 40 sensors in your home, the router only sees the gateway. one equipment. My multi-mode gateway 2 only costs 99 yuan, and one person can carry 28 devices. This is a good deal no matter how you calculate it.

Bluetooth devices are somewhere in between: You can connect directly with your mobile phone at a short distance, but for remote control, you need a Bluetooth gateway (speakers and some gateways come with this function) to be online for it. When choosing a model, don’t just look at the price of a single unit, but also calculate “how many seats will it occupy when you get home”.

Which devices use WiFi and which use gateways?: My selection comparison

It is not a brainless all-select gateway version. Each of the two types has irreplaceable scenarios. My current purchasing principle is based on the table below.:

Device type Which version to choose Why
Camera, sweeper, TV box Only WiFi direct connection To transmit a large amount of video traffic, Zigbee cannot handle it with its limited bandwidth.
smart speaker WiFi direct connection To respond in real time, we need to use the cloud to recognize speech.
Light bulbs, sockets, switches Prioritize Zigbee version The quantity is most likely to get out of control. Use the gateway to get rid of it once and for all.
Temperature and humidity, doors and windows, human body sensors Must choose Zigbee version Battery-powered, Zigbee standby power consumption is only a few tenths of that of the WiFi version
door lock Prioritize Zigbee/Bluetooth Local execution cannot be affected when the network is disconnected, details will be discussed later.

It’s worth saying a little more about the sensor.: The WiFi version of the temperature and humidity sensor generally needs to have its battery replaced every two or three months. The Zigbee version of my temperature and humidity sensor has been powered by a button battery for a year and a half and still has power. Because the WiFi chip must always be connected to the Internet even when it is in standby mode, the Zigbee device is usually asleep and only wakes up to report the number when there is an incident.

Another reminder, before buying, think about how much functionality the device will have left when the internet is disconnected. The article about the failure of the sweeping machine distribution network I mentioned the pitfalls of 2.4G, but here it is a matter of selection.: The camera is really blind when the network is disconnected, and the speaker becomes mute when the network is disconnected, but the Zigbee light bulbs and switches can still be pressed and linked locally after the network is disconnected - this determines whether your home's network failure will be "partially paralyzed" or "the whole house is mentally retarded".

2.4G is a public lane: Create a separate network for smart devices

With so many smart devices at home, the one most likely to be blocked is 2.4G. The reason is simple: Most of these IoT chips only recognize 2.4G. Mobile phones and computers run very fast on 5G, but 2.4G is crowded with light bulbs, sockets and sensors. Coupled with the neighbor's signal, the channel is the same as the subway in the morning rush hour.

My solution is "private network isolation"」: I dug out the dusty old AC2100, hung a network cable under the LAN port of the main router, and issued a separate SSID only for smart devices. After the old and new equipment were separated, the 2.4G traffic jam was immediately alleviated, and no matter how much the smart network segment was changed, it did not affect the main network - the access numbers and broadcast packets of the equipment were all trapped in the private network, and most of the main routes were cleared. If you don't have an old router, you can make do by setting up a guest network, but the guest network has the problem of isolating the direction. Some routers do not allow guest devices to access each other, and network association will be affected. You have to go to the backend to confirm the settings.

If there are dozens of devices, or you plan to use a WiFi6 router, OFDMA article The queuing mechanism mentioned is also worth a look - WiFi6 is indeed much more friendly to a bunch of IoT devices that "only send small packets" than WiFi5. But my attitude is: Things that can be solved by dividing network segments and selecting protocols, don’t rush to replace expensive routers.

Where to place the gateway and how to stagger the Zigbee channels?

For those who take the gateway route, the placement of the gateway is a new "router placement" issue. There are two pitfalls I have stepped on.

The first one is that Zigbee and WiFi run on the same 2.4G frequency band. If the two channels collide, they will interfere with each other. This is manifested as sensor data being lost every few minutes and the light bulb delaying response for a second or two. The solution is to stagger: If the 2.4G channel of your home WiFi is set to 1, Zigbee will choose 15 or 20 upwards. The multi-mode gateway can directly change the Zigbee channel in the Mijia App. After the change, the sub-device will automatically reconnect without reconfiguring each one.

Second, don’t stuff the gateway into a weak current box or metal cabinet. The transmission power of Zigbee is much weaker than that of WiFi. If it passes through a load-bearing wall, a large part of the signal will be lost. The metal box is like a cover for it. My gateway was finally placed on an open shelf in the living room, with the sensor in the center and farthest away from it separated by a wall - this position was determined by testing one sensor in each room.: If the reporting delay exceeds 3 seconds, it means that the signal is suspended, and it will be considered passed if it is moved within 2 seconds.

When the number of sub-devices increases, the gateway will also become a bottleneck. It is recommended to bring no more than 30 sub-devices for one gateway. In my home, 28 units is close to the upper limit. If there are more sub-devices, it is time to consider bringing a second gateway partition, such as one upstairs and one downstairs, which is more reliable than forcing the signal to be full.

Classification of consequences of disconnection: Which devices will be useless if the network is disconnected, and which ones will still work

The last step of planning is to sort the devices at home according to the "consequences of disconnection", which determines your network priority.:

  • If you break it, it will be really useless.: Cameras, smart speakers, and voice assistants that require the cloud—these need to ensure the stability of the 2.4G private network, and the router is scheduled to restart in the early morning when they are not working.
  • Half broken: Sweeper (cannot be started remotely, local cleaning can still run), WiFi version light bulb socket (cannot be controlled by mobile phone, physical switch is still there).
  • Even if it's broken, he'll run away: The light bulbs, switches, and sensors of the Zigbee gateway are linked - the automation performed locally by the gateway does not rely on the external network, and the "opening the door and automatically turning on the lights" function still works well when the network is disconnected.

That time my sweeper started up in the middle of the night, it was eventually found to be a firmware bug. However, during the investigation, I conveniently removed the 2.4G private network and replaced 6 of the 8 WiFi light bulbs with Zigbee versions. Since then, nothing like this has happened again. The device always shows offline troubleshooting article Suitable for remediation of problems that have already occurred, and what this article wants to say is: Most of the complaints about "the router can't be moved" are actually doomed on the shopping cart page where you buy the equipment.

Think about three things before adding equipment

Finally, I will post the three questions I ask before buying a smart device. If you follow them, the router will basically not be sold out.:

First question, is there a Zigbee version of this device? If you have one, don’t buy the WiFi version, especially if you have to buy more than three at a time (light bulbs, sockets, sensors). The second question is, how many functions does it still have after it is disconnected from the Internet? The fewer remaining functions, the more it should be placed on the most stable segment of the network. The third question is, is there still room for the current gateway at home? When the number 30 is almost reached, buy the second one in advance. Don’t wait until the sub-device goes offline every day before you remember it.

Whether a router can withstand it or not is never decided at the moment of purchase. It is the accumulation of multiple-choice questions about "which way to go" for each of these 49 devices. If you choose the right protocol, plan the dedicated network, and place the gateway correctly, a router of the AX3000T level can be used in an ordinary three-bedroom smart home.

Read More


Copyright Notice Scan to read on mobile
All Rights Reserved: 《SHUNOT》 => 《49 smart home routers, the WiFi version and the gateway version are more than a little different》
Article URL: https://www.shunot.com/en/zhonghe/840.html
Unless otherwise stated, all articles are original by 《SHUNOT》. Reposting is welcome! Please indicate the original URL when reposting, thank you.

Contact Us

Online Consultation: Click here to send me a message

WeChat ID: master_135

Scan to follow